Feb
12

What We Have Here is a Failure to THINK – Susan G. Komen and Sunday Coffee Contemplations

Could the ongoing Komen PR crisis have been avoided? Yes, simply by taking a step back and THINKING before acting. Komen didn’t take the time to THINK the situation through, to examine their actions from beyond the insiders’ perspective, and so they didn’t anticipate the overpowering backlash against their decision that resulted. Instead of remaining focused on their reason for existing, preventing and curing breast cancer, they stepped into a highly charged, highly sensitive political arena that had absolutely nothing to do with the organization’s main mission. They allowed their personal political beliefs to take over the Komen mission. As a result, Komen has damaged its brand, its constituents, and its legacy.

For PR peeps like me, morbidly watching the ongoing trainwreck that is Susan G. Komen is both pathetically funny and sadly predictable. We watched the drama unfold, silently thanking our lucky stars that we weren’t in the shoes of Leslie Aun, Komen’s Vice President of Marketing & Communications. Like many of my colleagues, I engaged in armchair quarterbacking the situation on Twitter and other social media sites. This past Tuesday, I confidently predicted to my class of PR and advertising students the imminent resignation of Komen executive Karen Handel, a former Republican candidate for governor of Georgia who made the defunding of Planned Parenthood a key part of her campaign; she was the apparent driving force behind the action. I gave Handel three days, which turned out to be wildly generous – she was gone before I made it back to my office from class. Read the rest of this entry »

Jan
01

PR New Year’s Resolutions – Sunday Coffee Contemplations

Happy New Year! It’s time for the obligatory New Year’s resolutions, which as one cartoon I spotted briefly last night and now can’t find, explained as a set of guidelines for the first week of January. I’m starting 2012 with a little more willpower than that, I hope.

So to play my part in this collective exercise, here are my PR resolutions for 2012:

  • I will stop using the words “marketing” or “markets” to describe what public relations does – it is a major contribution to the perpetual confusion surrounding PR in the business world.
  • I will point out professional misbehavior wherever and whenever I find it – it is only by holding ourselves to high professional standards that we, and our profession, will begin to gain the respect we deserve.
  • I correct misrepresentation of my profession when I encounter it, whether it be by journalists or members of the general public.
  • To repay the advice and assistance I received early in my career from veteran colleagues, I will mentor college students and young professionals, as they are the future of our profession.
  • I will educate non-PR business executives of the purpose and role of PR as a distinct business discipline, emphasizing the value of mid-career and senior-level professionals as strategic counselors at the highest levels of business.

What are your PR New Year’s resolutions?

- Debra

Dec
25

Six PR Skills in Short Supply – Sunday Christmas Coffee Contemplations

The end of the year is customarily a time for reflection on the past and prognostications for the future. This past week, PR maven (such an inadequate and overused word for someone who’s so much more) Gini Dietrich posted a list of six skills that every PR pro needs in this digital world on her blog Spin Sucks.

I initially read and agreed wholeheartedly with the list, but as I prepared for the holiday week, the post kept bugging me, popping back up into my thoughts at the oddest moments. Then last night, watching my techno-geek spouse exploring all the latest features on his new smartphone, I realized why: it’s all tech and marketing oriented. Not that it’s wrong, it isn’t. Gini is focusing on skills that PR needs to acquire to be effective in the future, and everything she listed is a definite must. But I think the present needs some help that it’s not currently getting.

As a profession, we have one advantage that we’re not exploiting to our benefit: our difference from marketing. Read the rest of this entry »

Nov
13

My Brother’s Keeper: When a Colleague Crosses the Line – Sunday Coffee Contemplations

What responsibility do you as an ethical public relations professional have when a colleague crosses the boundary and engages in unethical behavior? And no, I’m not referring to the child sex abuse situation at Penn State, but another ethical situation that slipped in under the radar this weekend: The case of Mike Winder, the director of public affairs for Summit Group Communications and currently mayor of West Valley, Utah, who admitted to creating a fake identity to “write stories for area newspapers in order to disseminate “good news” about his town.”

The Public Relations Society of America’s Code of Ethics clearly states “The value of member reputation depends upon the ethical conduct of everyone affiliated with the Public Relations Society of America. Each of us sets an example for each other – as well as other professionals – by our pursuit of excellence with powerful standards of performance, professionalism, and ethical conduct.” So….how are Winder’s colleagues to interpret that tomorrow when they go to work? Read the rest of this entry »

Oct
30

Why PR Can’t Write – Sunday Coffee Contemplations

There seems to be a universal complaint that young public relations professionals can’t write. At the 2011 Public Relations Society of America International Conference this month, I ended up in several discussions about the lack of good writers and how it’s a problem for the profession.

There’s a very good reason for the lack of good writer’s in the PR profession – we’re refusing to hire them. Read the rest of this entry »

Sep
18

What Makes Good Grammar – Sunday Coffee Coffee Contemplations

Watching Hugh Laurie on CBS Sunday Morning the day after grading papers, it suddenly struck me how grammatically correct his speech is, which is not normally the case. Written English and spoken English are usually very distinctly different, especially when you are dealing with American English instead of the Queen’s own.

So what about Hugh Laurie prompted me to start contemplating the subject of grammar? It was the fact that despite being spoken, his language was absolutely, perfectly correct…and it didn’t sound awkward when spoken, as written grammar often does. Read the rest of this entry »

Sep
11

9/11 Memories: Sunday Coffee Contemplations

Sitting here with my morning coffee, watching the ABC broadcast of the 9/11 Memorial, they played a clip of the late Peter Jennings saying, after the second tower collapsed, “It’s hard to put it into words; and maybe one doesn’t need to.”

Sometimes the silence is the most appropriate word. Our thoughts and prayers for the loved ones of those lost ten years ago this morning.

 

Sep
04

Grammarian-in-Chief? Sunday Coffee Contemplations

Grammar and rhetorical skills are the most important qualities American voters use to decide who they will vote for in presidential elections. Beth Fouhy’s article, “Campaigns Find That Some Truths Are Inconvenient“, brought back something I’ve been pondering for a long time now: our habit of parsing the comments of politicians and business leaders, looking for hidden truths in the words chosen, and interpreting what was not said as much as in what was said. You’d think that all that examination would make us incredibly wise and thoughtful voters. I’m not so sure that’s the case. Read the rest of this entry »

Jul
31

Why Do Marketers Ruin Everything? Sunday Coffee Contemplations

Why does marketing seem to ruin every new communication tool? President Obama is in hot water today with the Twitterverse for sending repeated tweets urging that followers put pressure on their legislators over the budget impasse. Mashable reports his account lost 36,000+ followers. As more and more people flock to Twitter (yes, pun definitely intended) the fundamental idea that people could interact in 140 characters has been lost. Instead, we’re inundated with blast tweets designed to push products and services, and, in this case, win an election.

Read the rest of this entry »

Jun
19

Living in Fantasy Land – Sunday Coffee Contemplations

I just read an interesting take on political debate and discussion this morning on The Huffington Post by Dan Sweeney: There’s No Arguing With Conservatives…No, Seriously, Scientific Studies Prove It. The researchers at Yale found that providing those with strong conservative beliefs with logically presented, factual refutations of false statements of Bush era policies, such as the whole Iraq weapons of mass destruction issue, only reinforced their incorrect beliefs. They found that the presentation of factual proof that was contrary to the initial belief just increased the incorrect belief and the subjects resistance to changing that belief. Wonder if the same applies to liberal viewpoints? It does, according to the Yale study.

Makes me wonder if that determination to believe false information carries over to other areas, outside of politics? What implications does that have for public relations campaigns? Something to contemplate over my coffee this morning.

Older posts «